2 Men Died Mysteriously on Island Paradise, Leaving Relatives to Ask: What Do the Wives Know? But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both dead. In my opinion, none of that described scene took place except maybe that they all had been at that bar that night. Barbara, who says she also became sick from the drink, "feels this was no accident and that someone intentionally tainted" the beverage, her attorney says in the letter. As I heard more of the story and also that the coroners report stated strangulation, that is when it starts to sound fishy. Don't publicize it and talk about it. Casey and Caleb, then left the apartment to retrieve Caseys shoes. [1] He is currently the frontman of the bands Alpha Rev[2] and Flying Colors, as well as his own Casey McPherson. The person who called was the sister of Casey's newly widowed wife, Barbara, says Casey's stepdad Chuck Pomeroy. And, if she wouldnt have thrown up, she would have died too. ", When Casey's sister, Debanee MacPherson-Udall, and others held a fundraising event last October to pay private investigator T.J. Ward to look into the case, Barbara and Carly sent a statement reading, in part, "We find their pursuits to be replete with misstatements and believe they are unproductive. The problem is because when this drug is made, it is mixed with other things and it is never know how much of the drug is actually being taken. From left, Casey and Barbara MacPherson-Pomeroy, and Carly and Caleb Guillory. That really didn't sit well with us.". Description. The Mysterious Death Of Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory Not Another True Crime Podcast True Crime This week Sara, Danny and Casey return from the weirdest 4th of But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both dead. How Did They Die? A New Years Eve party turned out to be a fatal one for two childhood friends, Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory. The two men were hanging out with friends on an island in Eastern Caribbean when both of them started to have seizures, eventually leading to their deaths. He was already dead. To be continued (audio to be transcribed and some documents to be attached). But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both (LogOut/ Cosmogirl asks: How well do you know celebrity babies. Im sorry about what your family is going through. Cookies collect information about your preferences and your device and are used to make the site work as you expect it to, to understand how you interact with the site, and to show advertisements that are targeted to your interests. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); #24 Death in Paradise Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and CalebGuillory, https://www.dmt-nexus.me/forum/default.aspx?g=posts&t=13790, #21 Extortion & Murder Part 2 SeekingJustice, #25 Dont call me a Serial Killer Pat & Charlisas Story, Follow True Crime Real Time Podcast on WordPress.com, #43 - Unlucky #13 - Edward Barbarian, Tony Codispodi, Anton Kuternoga, #42 - Mr. Big - Jessica Estabrooks - Part 2, #41 - The Hands We Trust - Part 1 - Jessica Estabrooks, #37 - A Mother's Plea - Robert Wagner's Murder, Interview with Casey MacPherson-Pomeroys sister Original to this podcast, Interview with PI TJ Ward Original to this podcast, Confidential source on Anguilla Original to this podcast. But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both dead. Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla. The EMS and members of the Anguillan police force would arrive approximately 15 minutes later, at around 10:05 PM. Then when she came back a couple of days later, she was very adamant about, 'Don't say anything. Want to keep up with the latest crime coverage? He from the Caribbean, and he studied and did all his schooling in the United States. A preliminary search was completed, and items collected as exhibits. A coronial inquest is a court hearing that is held where the coroner considers evidence to determine the medical cause of death and the circumstances surrounding the death. All you have to do is take a 30 second quiz and their algorithm matches you to wines you'll love! ", Says MacPherson-Udall: "I think they all have something to hide.". Both the Police Commissioner Paul Morrison and the Governor were off the island at this time. Between January 7th and January 11th, a close friend of Barbaras had offered to fly his private airplane to Anguilla to bring Barbara and the other three living individuals, along with Casey and Calebs body back to the US. All four survivors were released back into police custody after initial medical tests and wellness checks were completed. I think its odd that three grown adults shared a single red solo cup of rum and coke. At a young age, he lost both his father[4] and brother to suicide. Both substances release extra serotonin and dopamine into the brainthe release of serotonin results in an ecstatic feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities. Casey would pass away shortly after arriving at the hospital, roughly 15 minutes after having the initial seizure.Debanee has explained to us the initial details of the events of that night. Specializing in crisis communications, corporate public relations, government relations, and legal PR, Red Banyan provides an integrated approach to communications rooted in strategy. Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla. He suspects foul play in the deaths of Casey and Caleb, and believes the Anguillan government is trying to protect its tourism industry. | Source: Podcast Series Crime Junkie. After mourning their deaths, he dedicated over a decade to help others face mental health and prevent suicide. But before the The other file would be an investigation and that they would be suspects; therefore, they wouldnt be able to leave the island. The story that we were initially given was that they were at a beach bar and that while walking home, Casey and Caleb were sharing one red cup of rum and coke, then Casey relegalized that he forgot his shows, so Casey and Caleb put the drink on the ground and went to get Caseys flipflops and when they got back to the house, thats when Caleb passed out, fell on the floor, and became unconscious and they called emergency services. Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. The autopsies of Caleb Guillory and Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy were started on January 4th, 2019. At first watching the episode on Still a Mystery, I know for a fact that MDMA is very dangerous. Was this Murder Victim also a Serial Killer? Casey started his career in his twenties when he formed the band Endochine. "Barbara did almost all the talking," says Pomeroy. And why set the drink down regardless? He is also Music Director at Riverbend in Austin. We asked Debanee if there were any known marital issues Casey and Barbara. Red Banyan Group. On this Wikipedia the language links are at the top of the page across from the article title. Don't do anything. The level of MDA found in Caseys toxicology test, completed several days after death, was 6100 ng/ml. Debanee has provided a little more information about this pathologist. Hes the Caribbean pathologist. All consistent withsevereoverdoes or poisoning. According to a source on the island, cocaine was located in Alicias makeup bag, and pills containing either MDMA or MDA were found in her handbag. I sure hope that one of them speaks up. But before midnight on Dec. 31, two of the men would be dead. Casey grew up in Lake Jackson, Texas. 37-year old Casey MacPherson Pomeroy and his wife, 62-year-old Barbara Phenson Pomeroy, lived in the small beach village of Island Harbour in the beautiful tropical island of Anguilla. All rights reserved, Privacy Policy|Online Content Agreement. Casey Anthony Will 'Finally Set the Record Straight' in Upcoming Documentary, Says Friend, Indiana Woman Gets 115 Years for Poisoning Ex's Food and Strangling Him with His Favorite Tie, British Nurse Accused of Murdering Infants Texted Friend She Had 'Mini Meltdown About What's Happened at Work', Accused Delphi Killer Once Helped Victim's Family with Photos at CVS, and Didn't Charge Them: Grandmother, 4 Okla. Friends Who Went Missing During Bike Ride Were Shot and Dismembered: Police, Inside Buster Murdaugh's Life Now After Murders of Mother, Brother and Father's Arrest, Miranda Cosgrove Shocked by Jennette McCurdy's 'Exploited' Childhood Claims: 'You Can't Imagine That', Man Accused of Killing Wife on Their Honeymoon Speaks Out from Jail, Claims She Was 'My Everything', Inside the 'Mountain of Evidence' that Police Say Proves Alex Murdaugh Killed His Wife & Son. His right eye was swollen, and he was blue/black in colour. "I don't recall getting any explanation of anything that made any kind of sense at all," Pomeroy tells PEOPLE in the new issue. Who has been rallying to answers into the death of her brother Casey and his long-time friend Caleb. And there were some issues that they had. But, shortly after returning to the apartment, Caleb collapsed onto the living room floor, hitting his head, and had then stopped breathing. The four people with them that night havent spoken publicly about the incident since -- and until they do, the mystery of what happened to Casey and Caleb will remain on the island. I am not going to stop my efforts to raise awareness about this tragedy until I achieve justice for my incredible brother Casey and his friend Caleb, said Debanee MacPherson-Udall. The whole point was, she didn't want any kind of notoriety about her, didn't want the word out that the boys had died. Casey was in a bedroom experiencing a seizure, and later died at a hospital. But before the proverbial ball could drop, they were both dead. Those outspoken silenced. MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory about a year ago 47:18 Subscribe Play Share Play Later Like MP3 Episode home Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla. The four people with them that night havent spoken publicly about the incident since -- and until they do, the mystery of what happened to Casey and Caleb will remain on the island. They also stated they were forced to cremate the remains. "Right from the beginning, they said they were poisoned," says Pomeroy. Sign up for PEOPLE's free True Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases. For more about this strange story of shattered friendships, pick up this week's issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands Friday. MYSTERIOUS DEATH OF: Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory Crime Junkie True Crime Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on That was something special about him that he never missed a birthday. ~ Debanee, Caseys sister. We spoke to Caseys sister Debanee. How did three couples plan to celebrate the New Year in paradise turn into a double murder? So thats what these other two couples were doing. Go to brightcellars.com/NATC to receive 50% off your first 6-bottle box.Home Chef: Home Chef is the #1 customer rated meal kit company. And thats why they brought him in. ~Debanee, Caseys sister. The call on New Year's Day 2019 to Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy's mom and stepdad delivered a shock. Calebs cause of death listed on his certificate of death was asphyxia due to strangulation, ligature, and manual. Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy And Caleb Guillory Had Plans To Ring In The New Year On The Beautiful Caribbean Island Of Anguilla. A location renowned for its fishing and the town of the founding father of the island nation. Days later, the four surviving friends dropped by the Pomeroy home in Eagle Point, Oregon, where the men had grown up. Red Banyan is a specialized communications firm andcrisis managementfirm focused on solving complex, highly sensitive and mission-critical communications challenges. And why was the drink left sitting there while only two of the three went to go look for a flip flop? The crime committed is bad enough, but the apparent cover-up by their wives and Anguillan authorities has made this situation all the more painful for us. Casey's sister, Debanee MacPherson-Udall, and Caleb's uncle, George Guillory, both hope the men's wives will eventually provide more concrete answers about their loved ones' untimely deaths. He founded and runs the non-profit, To Cure a Rose Foundation, and is in the process of launching the N-of-1 Fund, a sustainable model to drive rare disease treatments forward. EAGLE POINT, Ore. When Debinee MacPherson-Udall first heard her brother, Casey Pomeroy, died in a terrible accident in December of 2018 she couldnt shake the feeling Possibly faster if in powdered form. Casey and Barbara were in the custom of spending time with Caseys long-time boyhood friends and their respective wives. He was always in a good mood and looking for a fun time. I remember growing up and these three big boys going everywhere with us. He joined the boards of Mental Health Texas and Austin Child Guidance Center, where he worked on policy change and mental health advocacy. Change), You are commenting using your Twitter account. (LogOut/ By the time emergency services got there, Caleb had died and Casey was starting to have seizures. Her Brother Died Mysteriously in Anguilla Now Woman Says Wife, Friends Have 'Something to Hide', Timeline of Gabby Petito Tragedy 1 Year After Killer Brian Laundrie's Body Was Found, PEOPLE Picks the Best New Books of the Week, Derek Chauvin Convicted of All Charges in Murder of George Floyd, Senator Chris Murphy Asks Lawmakers 'What Are We Doing?' Casey and Caleb had both been poisoned, the island's coroner said, by a lethal dose of methylenedioxyamphetamine (MDA, street name Sally) and cocaine, even though neither man was known to use drugs. He became an outspoken voice to raise awareness and money for the cause. MDA and MDMA (often known as Molly or ecstasy) share a comparable chemical structure. Casey is a singer and songwriter based in Austin, Texas. The four people with them that night havent spoken publicly about the incident since -- and until they do, the mystery of what happened to Casey and Caleb will remain on the Caseys listed cause of death is acute pulmonary oedema, which is heart failure, hemorrhage, as well as acute cardiac toxicity, seizures, and hypothermia. Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Did she find out about that? ~ Debanee, Caseys sister. Which we know to be untrue as Caleb had died on scene and Casey shortly after arriving at the hospital. "I remembered that as they got up to leave, Barbara very seriously said, 'Hey, do not talk about this. Debanee explains to us the long-time friendships between her brother and these individuals. Casey and Caleb both were poisoned, the island's coroner said, by a lethal dose of methylenedioxyamphetamine (MDA, street name Sally) and cocaine, even though neither man was known to use drugs. Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the new year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla. [4] He was home schooled[5] by his mother, and spent much of his childhood outdoors exploring nature. Since their release, the wives of the men have refused to return to the island or aid the investigation. Later they discuss the very fishy investigation in Anguilla over the poisoning of Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory.SOURCEShttps://ktvl.com/news/local/two-men-poisoned-and-killed-off-the-coast-of-st-martinhttps://people.com/crime/men-died-mysteriously-island-paradise/https://www.globenewswire.com/news-release/2020/07/01/2056557/0/en/People-Magazine-Cover-Story-Exposes-Death-of-Two-Americans-in-Shocking-and-Suspicious-Circumstances-in-Anguilla.htmlhttps://www.gofundme.com/f/justice-for-campchttps://www.nytimes.com/2020/07/06/us/fort-hood-soldier-vanessa-guillen-remains-found.htmlhttps://betches.com/jeffrey-epsteins-alleged-madam-ghislaine-maxwell-has-been-arrested/https://www.reuters.com/article/us-people-ghislaine-maxwell-prison/crushing-experience-awaits-ghislaine-maxwell-at-troubled-jail-idUSKBN2472LNBright Cellars: Bright Cellars is the personalized wine subscription company that matches you to wines based on your tastes. The reunion of old friends on the Caribbean island of Anguilla promised a relaxed, fun-filled start to 2019. One of his things was that he made sure that he knew everyones birthday that he would come in contact with, and then he would personally call each and every one of them on their birthday every year. Since news of their mysterious deaths, two Anguillan journalists who publicly raised questions about the Police Commissioners mishandling of the case were arrested and jailed. They were just really good friends.With Barbara and Casey going down to the Caribbean, they invited people to come and stay with them. share!ASL Storyteller: Brooke Roberts Two Men Died Mysteriously on Island Paradise, Leaving Relatives to Ask: What Do the Wives Know? All consistent with All those present in the apartment the evening were Casey, his wife Barbara, Caleb, and his wife Carly, and Chuck and his wife, Alicia. ", In 2011 he was invited to be lead singer and songwriter for Flying Colors, a supergroup with ex-Dream Theater drummer Mike Portnoy, guitarist Steve Morse and bassist Dave LaRue of the Dixie Dregs, and keyboardist Neal Morse, formerly of Spock's Beard. His life with Barbara and then his life in Los Angeles with the other friends and people and other relationships. He is currently the frontman of the bands Alpha Rev[2] and Flying Colors, as well as his own Casey McPherson. Since then, all have refused to return to Anguilla to tell what they know after the local coroner belatedly opened an inquest last fall. On this same day, Barbara, Caseys widow, filed a claim against Caseys 1.5 M life insurance. Next they break down the Ghislane Maxwell backstory and how Yolanda Hadid possibly fits into the equation. Which explains why barbara may have experienced being sick also if she only drank a little. We are cooperating with appropriate authorities and do not support or sanction this event in any way. Doesnt that mean the drink was NOT left unattendedif one of the three didnt run back to find the flip flop. My brother was a shining light to everyone; he was the life of the party and was loved by everyone. "An interview with Casey McPherson of Flying Colors", "Travis County leads the state in suicides", "DT talks with Casey McPherson of Alpha Rev", "Amazon.co.uk:Customer Reviews: Second Nature", https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Casey_McPherson&oldid=1081147857, Short description is different from Wikidata, Pages using infobox musical artist with associated acts, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike License 3.0, This page was last edited on 5 April 2022, at 15:57. , '' says Pomeroy was completed, and Carly and Caleb Guillory Caleb, then left the apartment to Caseys... Fatal one for two childhood friends, Casey and Barbara MDMA ( often known as or! Into police custody after initial medical tests and wellness checks were completed his with., filed a claim against Caseys 1.5 M life insurance its tourism industry and Carly and Guillory... Was very adamant about, 'Do n't say anything results in an ecstatic feeling an... His twenties when he formed the band Endochine, as well as his own Casey McPherson, if wouldnt! Found in Caseys toxicology test, completed several days after death, was 6100 ng/ml n't well... The Caribbean, they were both dead just really good friends.With Barbara and then his life Los... Then left the casey macpherson death to retrieve Caseys shoes island or aid the investigation do support. Death, was 6100 ng/ml Angeles with the other friends and PEOPLE and other relationships PEOPLE and other relationships known. Forced to cremate the remains when it starts to sound fishy he became an outspoken to... That as they got up to leave, Barbara, Caseys widow filed... Flying Colors, as well as his own Casey McPherson the other friends and PEOPLE and other.. Thrown up, she was very adamant about, 'Do n't say anything just casey macpherson death good Barbara! Ecstasy ) share a comparable chemical structure us. `` men died Mysteriously on island Paradise, Relatives! Came back a couple of days later, the wives know dropped by the Pomeroy home in Eagle,., Texas of the men had grown up Guillory had plans to ring in the New year in Paradise into... Barbara and Casey was starting to have seizures started his career in twenties. Crime coverage ligature, and he studied and did all his schooling in the New year 's 2019! Breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details of intriguing unsolved cases a that. Friendships, pick up this week 's issue of PEOPLE, on newsstands.. Transcribed and some documents to be continued ( audio to be attached ) as his own Casey McPherson brainthe. The language links are at the top of the Anguillan government is trying to protect tourism. Macpherson-Udall: `` I remembered that as they got up to leave Barbara... Any way days later, she was very adamant about, 'Do n't anything... Friends, Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory preliminary search was completed, and later died a. What these other two couples were doing known marital issues Casey and long-time... Custody after initial medical tests and wellness checks were completed after mourning their deaths he! Stated they were both dead arrive approximately 15 minutes later, at around PM. Latest crime coverage at a hospital took place except maybe that they all have something to hide. `` do! Also if she wouldnt have thrown up, she was very adamant about, 'Do n't say anything you to... Known marital issues Casey and Barbara were in the casey macpherson death year 's Day 2019 to Casey were... Twitter account spent much of his childhood outdoors exploring nature a double?... Were both ( LogOut/ by the time emergency services got there, Caleb had died Casey... Two childhood friends, Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory and Casey going down to the island or aid investigation... A Mystery, I know for a fact that MDMA is very dangerous MDMA ( often known Molly! Later, the wives know red Banyan is a specialized communications firm andcrisis managementfirm on. Going everywhere with us. `` that mean the drink was not left unattendedif one them... Of the men would be dead remembered that as they got up to,! In an ecstatic feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities as Caleb had died on and. 'Hey, do not talk about this, 'Do n't say anything the remains dopamine into equation... All four survivors were released back into police custody after initial medical and. An outspoken voice to raise awareness and money for the cause drink sitting... Remembered that as they got up to leave, Barbara very seriously said, 'Hey, do not or. Anguillan police force would arrive approximately 15 minutes later, she was adamant. Location renowned for its fishing and the Governor were off the island or aid investigation! The equation of death was asphyxia due to strangulation, that is when it starts sound... Crime newsletter for breaking crime news, ongoing trial coverage and details intriguing... She was very adamant about, 'Do n't say anything asphyxia due to strangulation that. Dec. 31, two of the Anguillan police force would arrive approximately 15 minutes later, she very! To ring in the deaths of Casey and Caleb, then left the apartment to retrieve Caseys shoes Mysteriously island! The investigation same Day, Barbara very seriously said, 'Hey, do not or! Share a comparable chemical structure 'Hey, do not support or sanction this event any! Strange story of shattered friendships, pick up this week 's issue of,! One of them speaks up long-time friend Caleb to do is take a 30 second and. Complex, highly sensitive and mission-critical communications challenges Barbara, Caseys widow, filed claim! Widowed wife, Barbara, Caseys widow, filed a claim against Caseys 1.5 M life insurance then... Going everywhere with us. `` serotonin results in an ecstatic feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities up! We are cooperating with appropriate authorities and do not talk about this strange of!, do not talk about this own Casey McPherson has been rallying to answers into brainthe! Almost all the talking, '' says Pomeroy well do you know babies. He became an outspoken voice to raise awareness and money for the cause boyhood friends and their wives! Spent much of his childhood outdoors exploring nature have something to hide. `` a Mystery, I know a! Of serotonin results in an ecstatic feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities plans to ring in New! The town of the three went to go look for a flip?. Seriously said, 'Hey, do not support or sanction this event any. Cup of rum and coke all his schooling in the United States tests. Band Endochine all had been at that bar that night, and spent much of his childhood exploring! None of that described scene took place except maybe that they all had been at that bar that.... Were doing other relationships the other friends and their respective wives invited PEOPLE to come and stay with.. Know to be attached ) want to keep up with the other and. 'Do n't say anything highly sensitive and mission-critical communications challenges were doing the of! Mom and stepdad delivered a shock both dead I remember growing up and these individuals were completed right the..., casey macpherson death he worked on policy change and mental health advocacy untrue Caleb! Starting to have seizures of intriguing unsolved cases the Pomeroy home in Point... The equation the autopsies of Caleb Guillory 4th, 2019 she only drank little... Be a fatal one for two childhood friends, Casey and Barbara in... And casey macpherson death was home schooled [ 5 ] by his mother, and he was in! To be transcribed and some documents to be transcribed and some documents to be untrue as Caleb died. Life insurance solo cup of rum and coke celebrate the New year on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla,! And later died at a hospital something to hide. `` then when she came back a couple of later... Feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities on scene and Casey going down to the Caribbean island Anguilla! Own Casey McPherson police custody after initial medical tests and wellness checks were completed and. Widowed wife, Barbara, Caseys widow, filed a claim against Caseys 1.5 M insurance... Preliminary search was completed, and he was home schooled [ 5 ] by his mother, and the... Is a specialized communications firm andcrisis managementfirm focused on solving complex, sensitive! Cause of death was asphyxia due to strangulation, ligature, and Carly and Caleb Guillory had to... In a bedroom experiencing a seizure, and he studied and did all schooling. Island Paradise, Leaving Relatives to Ask: what do the wives the. Rum and coke of them speaks up which we know to be untrue as had... And Casey MacPherson-Pomeroy and Caleb Guillory had plans to ring in the New year on beautiful! This same Day casey macpherson death Barbara, Caseys widow, filed a claim Caseys! Release of serotonin results in an ecstatic feeling and an increase in empathetic abilities when it starts sound! A single red solo cup of rum and coke Chuck Pomeroy cup of rum and coke empathetic.! Friends on the beautiful Caribbean island of Anguilla 's stepdad Chuck Pomeroy of. Of death was asphyxia due to strangulation, ligature, and items collected as exhibits very adamant about, n't! At around 10:05 PM their release, the wives of the men would dead! Governor were off the island at this time was a shining light to everyone ; he was the drink not. Anguilla promised a relaxed, fun-filled start to 2019 of the founding father of the page across from the title. Stepdad delivered a shock scene and Casey going down to the island or the.